Every number is Russ’s own rating out of 10. Russ has previously stated that he never scores in sponsored videos, so the food he reviews carries no applied pressure or bias.
The returning Paddle Pop Thick Shake, now in a 1L tub. Russ says it has the exact same taste but the texture should be softer, so he mixes it into a slop. He rates it 8/10, about the same as he remembers. He compares it to an aerated chocolate Paddle Pop mixed with a Maccas chocolate thick shake.