
23 May 2026 · Sheep Dog Peanut Butter & Jelly Review
Better than the original; the jelly is what it was missing
New Sheep Dog Peanut Butter & Jelly flavoured whiskey (30%), tried with milk. Nutty peanut butter, then jam, with a slight whiskey burn in the aftertaste. Rated 9/10 and better than the original peanut butter version. The end-of-video 9/10 overlay shows the original Peanut Butter Whiskey bottles, but the spoken rating refers to the PB&J.
Liked
- that is fucking awesome
- It is perfect for winter
What it’s like


















